The three reward currencies
Cash back: the simplest. A percentage of each purchase comes back as a statement credit or deposit. Value is fixed and transparent.
Flexible points (Amex Membership Rewards, Chase Ultimate Rewards, Scene+): transferable to airline and hotel partners, where they can be worth 1.5–2x their cash value — if you learn the transfer game.
Airline/hotel points: earned with one program (Aeroplan, Marriott Bonvoy). Best if you're loyal to that brand; risky if you're not, because the program controls the value.
Match the card to your spending, not the billboard
Pull up three months of statements and total your spending by category. A card paying 5x on groceries beats a flat 2% card only if groceries are a big share of your budget.
Annual fees are a math problem, not a dealbreaker: a $120 fee is worth it if the extra rewards over a no-fee card exceed $120 a year. Do the arithmetic with your real numbers.
The rules that keep rewards profitable
Never carry a balance. A 20%+ interest rate erases 2–5% rewards instantly.
Watch category caps — many high rates only apply to the first $500–$6,000 of annual spending in that category.
Redeem regularly. Points programs devalue over time; points sitting unredeemed are points losing value.