Flat-rate vs category cards
Flat-rate cards (like the Wells Fargo Active Cash at 2% on everything) are the floor: zero thought, decent return. Everyone's wallet should beat or match 2% on average.
Category cards pay 3–6% in specific areas — groceries, gas, dining, streaming — and 1% elsewhere. They win when your spending concentrates in their bonus categories.
The two-card stack most households should use
Pair one strong category card with one flat-rate card: use the category card where it earns its bonus, and the flat card for everything else.
Example: a 4% grocery card plus a 2% flat card turns a $30,000/year household spend into roughly $700–$800 back, versus $300 on a weak 1% card.
Read the fine print on caps
Many headline rates have ceilings: 6% on groceries 'up to $6,000 per year' means everything past $500/month earns 1%.
Rotating-category cards (5% in categories that change quarterly) require activation each quarter — set a calendar reminder or the card earns 1%.
In Canada, the Tangerine Money-Back card lets you pick your own 2% categories with no annual fee — a good starter stack for Canadian households.